One thing about the European Middle Ages (that were a
thousand years long period with many changes and
transformation bla bla bla) is that they were very isolated
and honestly, poor. Yes, the Silk Road existed and there were
even European communities in Persia and China (but they also
decayed), yes there was lots of art and culture and such. But
Europe was still a rather isolated and poor part of the world,
no matter if we now understand the Middle Ages were more
complex.
(and in the early dark ages, yes, it WAS that bad, with
cities shrinking to the size of old Roman amphitheaters and
the overall quality of life for everyone diminishing with
trade routes severed everywhere and literacy and
infrastructure dropping. Don’t think that just because it
wasn’t a completely dark time and things still went on, it
wasn’t bad)
ANYWAYS, my point is that most of the things we associate
with “medieval” fantasy and worlds are actually from the
Renaissance and Early Modern Age. Those worldbuilding pedants
(and my friends) focused on military matters point out the
plate armor and weapons, others point out the availability of
books and literacy and architecture, I point out the food and
luxury items that you just couldn’t find otherwise…
And that does imply something. It implies a connected
world, one that is very much more modern. It implies trade
networks to bring a whole host of exotic and luxury goods
(transoceanic networks, if we are talking about things only
found in the tropics, since virtually all modern fantasy is
set in temperate areas but I ranted about that elsewhere), it
implies printing press and increased literacy, it implies an
increase on wealth to afford all those things, and places
where those goods and wealth came from… specifically
colonialism (but we don’t wanna talk about that, right? you
don’t want me to go quoting Eduardo Galeano right?).
And those things also imply MORE; social and religious
conflict, the dawn of modern science, trade networks,
intercultural contact, and again, colonialism and imperialism.
And that clashes with the general fantasy plot of good and
evil kingdoms in a mostly static world (still from the classic
view of the European Dark Ages), where technology, society and
even individual dynasties don’t change for centuries or
millennia. All with the trappings of a society in full change.
People love their princesses with silk dresses eating
chocolate, their knights with plate armor eating potato stew,
and wizards with huge libraries in cities that can allow
enough wealth to employ them, but don’t want to think that
this might not be signs of a static theme park world, but a
world that was increasingly interconnected and changing, like
our early modern age. (and thus, an interesting story)
And why don’t you want to learn about those changes that
built our modern world? The cultures where most of the things
you take from granted came from? (some, in my opinion, could
be more well known in the west…) Why the boring coup-out of
“it’s just magic XD” when you could think a little more and
create something interesting?
So no, it’s not just about potatoes, but it’s a good question
to ask first.